File sharing is has been an issue for many years now, arguably starting with the popularity of music sharing site Napster. Although Napster has been closed down the illegal act of file sharing still continues and is feared to be growing and impacting on all forms of the media industry; music, film, games, software and publishing. For those that are not aware file sharing is the copying and downloading of files through the internet. It is currently an illegal thing to do but the pressure of so many users may see a huge change.
After being given the details to the debate we are to have on file-sharing and copyright, the class was put into equal groups. The group I am in is against the motion of file-sharing and will put a case together why file-sharing has a negative impact on the media industry.The group decided to meet up after the workshop to discuss how we would approach the debate. We decided to divide the content between us, each looking into a particular aspect of file-sharing. My specific aspect was the peer-to-peer sites such as; Napster and The Pirate Bay. And the impacts of these such sites.
It is clear from the debate and by peoples personal use of all kinds of media that file sharing is an issue that everyone is apart of. The internet not only facilitates the actual act of file sharing but also helps separates the user from the product, by creating this distance the users feels like they aren't doing anything wrong and that its a innocent act. However it loses its innocence when compared to stealing a CD, DVD or game from a store such as HMV. The debate brought up many other good points for and against file sharing, it is a hard issue to give a definite answer as there are so many sides to the issue. Although at the end of the day I feel, and I think the group reached a similar thought by the end of the debate, that it is a matter of choice. Artists should be able to have the choice to give their music away for free if that's what they want to do. Maybe this means that the conglomerates that own the music labels, film companies and other media companies need to have less control on the artist. After all the artist should be making the product for the passion, interest and cultural benefit of the media area. Though this may be my own personal, rose tinted view of it.
Here are my findings and main points for my argument against the motion of file sharing.
The Pirate Bay
The Pirate Bay contributed to research into file-sharing, it surveyed 75,000 users and called itself
The Survey Bay. The survey was the largest of its kind. The results were presented as graphs.
The graphs show;
- 23, 542 (31%) file-share everyday.
- When asked 'How do you see the future of file-sharing?'
46.958 (61.8) said "File-sharing will develop in ways that neither law or market can control". This shows disrespect to the law, market, media industry and the original creators. And Asks the question, will there be any profit in producing media products in the future?
Morally Wrong
Downloading and file-sharing through Peer-two-peer sites are a digitalised form of steeling. It is a virtual equivalent as someone taking a film, game or cd from HMV, it is wrong and illegal and cannot be seen as innocent just because of the distancing created by the internet.
Remixing
Arguments for file-sharing in terms of other artists contributing, remixing and creating is only a fraction of the actual percentage that illegally download and breach copyright law. Most people who do it are ordinary members of the public after the latest track or film, but don't want to pay for it.
File-Sharing Sites
There is a lot of money in the media industry, but if file-sharing takes over control it prevents anyone in the industry gaining access to the money, most importantly the artist/creator.
The money ends up going else- where, such as the torrent sites.
Consider the people making the sites, its not about the freedom of property to them, its not a charitable action.
- There are investors behind sites like The Pirate Bay (Napster before it closed down)
- Adverts make them money
- Finally they are all waiting for IPO (Initial Public Offer) offering, to sell shares of the company.
Artists Rights
Where does the people power stop?
When does an artist have the right to say enough? This is their 'intellectual property' which they have created and now its being given away for free. - Demoralising and unfair.
If you are a new artist or one that isn't very well known and you need a break into the industry, file sharing can be a route to get a name for yourself, gaining popularity. Yet consider how you'll start earning once in the business if people are so use to downloading your music for free.
But artists who don't want to shouldn't be forced into giving their music, films, games or software away for free. They were not even asked for permission to use their work.
Its about retaining control for those who do not want their 'intellectual property' to be given away.
Sources
http://www.thesurveybay.com/index.php
http://ohkera.com/advice-insight/blog/file-sharing-statistics-pirate-bay-offical-survey
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1OIqtHBbDWA
https://vimeo.com/8040182
https://sites.google.com/site/testsiteengl105/webtext